Ethical Policy

 

Our aim is to support the ethical publishing principles for all who are involved in Journal of Data Science (JDS) publishing with a summary of best practice guidance from leading organizations (e.g., COPE) around the world. Our guidelines are applicable to JDS journal editors, authors, and peer-reviewers. This journal is committed to upholding the integrity of the scientific record. The journal follows the COPE flowcharts on how to deal with potential acts of misconduct.

 

Conflicts of interest

To ensure objectivity, neutrality, and transparency in research and to ensure that accepted principles of ethical and professional conduct have been followed, authors and peer-reviewers participating in the manuscript submission stage should include information regarding sources of funding and potential conflicts of interest, financial or non-financial, – whether they actually had an influence. In most cases, this declaration will not stop work from being published nor will it always prevent someone from being involved in a review process. Undeclared interests may incur sanctions. Submissions with undeclared conflicts that are later revealed may be rejected. Published articles may need to be re-assessed, have a corrigendum published, or in serious cases be retracted.

The types of conflicts for the authors are:

  • research grants from funding agencies. Please give the information about the research funder and the grant number in the Acknowledgements part of the manuscript;
  • honoraria for speaking at conferences;
  • financial support for attending conferences;
  • financial support for educational programs;
  • employment or consultation;
  • support from a project sponsor;
  • position on an advisory board or board of directors or other types of management relationships;
  • multiple affiliations;
  • financial relationships, for example, equity ownership or investment interest;
  • intellectual property rights (e.g. patents, copyrights, and royalties from such rights);
  • references to the “predatory” journals;
  • holdings of spouse and/or children that may have a financial interest in the work;
  • personal relationships or competing interests directly or indirectly tied to this research;
  • professional interests or personal beliefs that may influence your research.

The corresponding author must collect the conflict of interest (listed above) disclosure from all authors and declare them on behalf of all authors during the manuscript submission stage in the Journal of Data Science (JDS). Declared conflicts of interest will be considered by the editor and reviewers.

JDS intends to prevent conflict of interest when assigning submissions to editors and inviting peer-reviewers. They should decline in any of the below situations occur and declare any conflicts to the journal. Peer-reviewers must declare their interests in the ‘Confidential’ section of the review form, which will be considered by the editor. Close competitors should consider declining. This information will not be made public.

The types of conflicts of interest for editors and peer-reviewers are:

  • editors and/or peer-reviewers have a recent publication or current submission with any author of the manuscript;
  • editors and/or peer-reviewers share or recently shared an affiliation with any author of the manuscript;
  • editors and/or peer-reviewers collaborate or recently collaborated with any author of the manuscript;
  • editors and/or peer-reviewers have a close personal connection to any author of the manuscript;
  • editors and/or peer-reviewers have a financial interest in the subject of the work of the manuscript;
  • editors and/or peer-reviewers feel unable to be objective for the manuscript.

 

Authorship and Contributorship

JDS requires each author to meet the following four criteria: (1) make a substantial intellectual contribution to the study, including its conception, methodology, software, data acquisition, analysis, or interpretation; (2) participate in drafting or substantively revising the manuscript; (3) approve the final version; and (4) accept responsibility for their contribution and cooperate in resolving questions about the integrity of the work.

Everyone meeting these criteria should be included as an author. Funding acquisition, general supervision, or administrative support alone does not qualify a person for authorship. Other contributions should be acknowledged with permission.

The corresponding author coordinates communication and confirms all authors' approval. Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors must explain the reasons and include written agreement from all affected authors. Unresolved authorship disputes may be referred to the relevant institutions.

 

Research and Publication Misconduct

JDS considers allegations of research and publication misconduct involving authors, peer reviewers, and editors at both the submission and post-publication stages. Such misconduct includes fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, redundant publication, inappropriate authorship, manipulation of peer review or citations, and concealment of significant competing interests.

Concerns and supporting evidence may be submitted to JDS@ruc.edu.cn. An editor without a conflict of interest will assess the available evidence, seek explanations from the relevant parties, and, where appropriate, cooperate with their institutions or other responsible bodies in investigating the allegations. Credible concerns will be assessed regardless of whether the complainant identifies themselves.

All allegations will be handled fairly and objectively, with appropriate measures to avoid conflicts of interest throughout the investigation and decision-making process.

Depending on the findings, JDS may suspend manuscript processing, reject a submission, or publish a correction, expression of concern, or retraction.

Individuals affected by editorial decisions may submit an appeal explaining the grounds for reconsideration. Appeals will be assessed by an editor who has no conflict of interest and was not responsible for the original decision.

 

Plagiarism and Text Recycling

JDS prohibits presenting another person's text, ideas, data, images, or code as original work without appropriate attribution. Authors must also disclose and cite relevant overlap with their own previous publications.

Editors assess suspected overlap in context, considering its extent, location, attribution, and effect on the originality of the work. A similarity percentage alone does not determine whether plagiarism has occurred.

Authors will be given an opportunity to respond to documented concerns. Before publication, confirmed problems may result in required revisions or rejection, depending on their nature and severity. After publication, JDS may issue a correction or retraction and, where appropriate, notify the relevant institutions, following its misconduct procedures.

 

Retractions

JDS may retract an article when its findings are substantially unreliable because of major errors, fabrication, or falsification, or when serious breaches of publication ethics are established, including plagiarism, redundant publication, unethical research, or manipulation of peer review.

Authors may request the retraction of their published articles. However, the final decision rests with the responsible, unconflicted Co-Editor, who will assess the available evidence and provide the authors with an opportunity to respond before making a decision. Author agreement is not required for a retraction, and disagreement by the authors does not necessarily prevent the journal from proceeding with a retraction.

A publicly accessible retraction notice will identify the article, explain the reasons for the retraction, and state who is retracting it. The notice and the original article will be linked to ensure transparency and traceability of the scholarly record. The retracted article will normally remain publicly available and be clearly marked as retracted.

 

Corrections and Expressions of Concern

Authors should promptly notify the editorial office of significant errors in their published work. Readers may also report concerns. JDS will assess the available evidence and determine whether a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction is appropriate.

A correction will be published when an error requires amendment but the article's main findings and conclusions remain reliable. If the errors or other issues are sufficiently serious to undermine the reliability of the article's main findings, or if other grounds for retraction are established, retraction will be considered in accordance with the journal's retraction policy.

A correction notice will describe the changes, indicate the date of publication, and be linked to the original article. Any updated version of the article will clearly identify the changes and their dates, and previous versions will be archived to maintain a transparent and traceable publication record.

When credible and significant concerns remain unresolved or an investigation is ongoing, JDS may publish an expression of concern to inform readers of the potential issues. The journal will subsequently communicate the outcome of the investigation and take further action, including correction or retraction, as appropriate.